Published September 19, 2006 | https://doi.org/10.63485/b9ccq-gxs67

RAE licensing instead of OA

Creators & Contributors

Stevan Harnad, Submitting one's own published work for assessment is Fair UseOpen Access Archivangelism, September 18, 2006.  Excerpt:

Summary: CrossRef and Publishers Licensing Society have come to a "gentleman's agreement" with RAE/HEFCE to "license" the papers that are submitted to RAE for assessment "free of charge." No such licensing agreement was necessary, however. The RAE's insistence on authors submitting the publisher's version of each paper for assessment, rather than the author's peer-reviewed final drafts (postprints) is arbitrary and serves no useful purpose. Moreover, the RAE needs no special permission for its individual authors to submit their work for assessment: that is merely Fair Use on the authors' part. The RAE restriction to only four submissions per author is likewise needless and counterproductive. Once the unnecessary and wasteful "peer-re-reviewing" by the RAE panels is at last abandoned in favour of metrics, there will be no need for either a 4-item cap or any attempt to get the "originals" to the panel. The authors' self-archived postprints in their own institutional OA IRs will suffice. What will moot all of this is the OA self-archiving mandates by RCUK and the UK universities themselves, which will fill the UK universities' IRs, which will in their turn -- with the help of the IRRA (Institutional Repositories and Research Assessment) -- mediate the submission of both the postprints and the metrics to the RAE.

Files

10.63485_b9ccq-gxs67.pdf

Files (99.5 kB)

Name Size Download all
md5:eb42aa4b265de3b3de8c2f193e6e79db
99.5 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Description

Stevan Harnad, Submitting one's own published work for assessment is Fair Use, Open Access Archivangelism , September 18, 2006.

Identifiers

GUID
tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-3536726.post-115868179464202686
URL
https://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/2006/09/rae-licensing-instead-of-oa.html

Dates

Issued
2006-09-19T00:00:00Z
Updated
2006-09-19T16:03:15Z